←Front page
PoliticsInternational

SMOKERS’ CORNER: The Migration Paradox

<figure class="media w-1/2 sm:w-3/5 media--center media--uneven media--stretch"> <div class="media__item "><img alt="" height="960" src="https://i.dawn.com/large/2026/11/20010833d53cb6c.webp" width="902" /></div> </figure> <p>Till the early 1970s, it was often believed that South Asians who travelled to Western countries for studies or migrated there, often adopted ‘Western values.’ In early Indian and Pakistani movies, Pakistanis and Indians returning from the West were often portrayed as enlightened, rational people who scoffed at the superstitious beliefs of their countrymen and women. By the mid-1970s, though, the portrayal of West-returned Pakistanis and Indians changed. They began being portrayed as stupid, dope-smoking, guitar-slinging hippies.</p> <p>But in the decades that followed, reality turned out very differently. Instead of becoming less religious or adopting ‘immoral’ lifestyles, many South Asians living abroad actually became much more religious than their relatives back home. Anyone travelling between major South Asian cities and the suburbs of Western cities can see this contrast.</p> <p>In South Asia, religion is a natural part of everyday life, heard in the call to prayer or seen at local temples. People do not have to work hard to keep it alive. Abroad, however, mosque and temple attendance becomes stricter, food rules become more rigid, and dogmatic religious rules often replace the relaxed, mixed traditions practised back home. According to the American anthropologist Steven Vertovec, moving to a new country rarely weakens religious belief. Instead, it often makes people more conscious of their faith. This change happens because of a deep desire to protect one’s culture, and the political reality of living as a minority in a foreign land.</p> <p>Leaving South Asia means leaving behind extended families, friends, familiar streets and unspoken social rules. In Western countries, society focuses heavily on individual independence and small nuclear families, which can make newcomers feel lonely. Religion fills this void.</p> <blockquote class="blockquote-level-1"> <p>South Asian immigrant communities in the secular West have often developed stricter religious identities than their counterparts back home. What explains this paradox?</p> </blockquote> <p>According to the Terror Management Theory developed by psychologists Jeff Greenberg, Sheldon Solomon and Tom Pyszczynski, when people feel anxious because their familiar world has disappeared, they hold on tighter to their core beliefs to feel secure. The mosque, temple or the gurdwara in a Western country offers this, more than they do in the homeland of the immigrants.</p> <p>In his book Religions of Immigrants from India and Pakistan, the American sociologist Raymond B. Williams posits that religious outlets abroad become the main places where immigrants reinstate their otherwise unsure presence. Inside these spaces, they are no longer treated as outsiders. According to multiple surveys by the Pew Research Centre, daily prayers and rituals act as emotional anchors that connect immigrants to their ‘heritage.’</p> <figure class="media w-full sm:w-4/5 media--center media--uneven media--stretch"> <div class="media__item "><img alt=" Illustration by Abro " height="612" src="https://i.dawn.com/large/2026/11/2001085951ecfc0.webp" width="1200" /></div> <figcaption class="media__caption ">Illustration by Abro</figcaption> </figure> <p>Back in South Asia, a person’s identity is naturally supported by local languages, movies, food and festivals. One does not need to visit a temple to feel Indian, or a mosque to feel Pakistani as such, because the whole society reinforces that identity. Abroad, however, the pressure to blend in is strong, indicated by the fear shown in 1970s Urdu and Hindi movies about ‘Westernised’ youth. Worried that their children will forget their roots, immigrant parents use special religious classes outside the curriculum in secular Western countries.</p> <p>The British scholar Pnina Werbner, in her studies of British Pakistanis, talks about a “cultural freeze.” While people in South Asia continue to debate, modernise and change their views over time, immigrant communities often freeze the religious and social rules of the exact decade they left. A family that left Lahore or Ahmedabad in the 1980s might strictly follow conservative rules that their own cousins back home are likely to have moved away from.</p> <p>The Pakistani-American historian Ayesha Jalal and the French scholar Olivier Roy point out that the blended traditions of South Asia do not travel well. According to Roy’s idea of “deculturation”, when religion is separated from its home soil, what survives is a simpler, literalist and stricter version of it. Becoming more religious abroad is also driven by politics, shaped by political tensions brought over from South Asia. In many Western countries, especially under multicultural policies, governments organise immigrant groups by their religion rather than their language or region.</p> <p>As the British-Pakistani political sociologist Tariq Modood has demonstrated, British citizens from South Asia quickly realised that local councils, politicians and the media in the West do not deal with them as members of an ethnic group, but as ‘British Muslims’, ‘American Hindus’ or ‘Canadian Sikhs.’ Due to the fact that the government recognises general religious labels, people have a strong reason to organise around their faith if they want a political voice.</p> <p>At the same time, rising prejudice, Islamophobia and anti-immigrant attitudes trigger what American sociologists Alejandro Portes and Rubén Rumbaut call “reactive religion.” According to their research, when a minority group feels judged, turning toward religion becomes a way to defend themselves. Wearing visible religious symbols such as a hijab, a turban or a tilak becomes a public statement of strength — at least to the wearers.</p> <p>This is made even stronger by what the Irish political scientist Benedict Anderson terms as “long-distance nationalism.” Free from the daily struggles of living in South Asia, many immigrants develop an idealised version of their homeland, or what it ought to be like. The American anthropologist Arjun Appadurai explains in his book Modernity at Large that television and social media bring the bitter religious/sectarian/communal conflicts of South Asia straight into immigrant living rooms. With more money to spare and a desire to prove their loyalty to their home country, some people abroad eagerly fund religious groups and political parties back home, taking part in homeland politics from a safe distance.</p> <p>The old movie image of the modern, non-religious ‘West-returned’ traveller gave way to fears of ‘Western immorality’ and finally to a reality where immigrants became more conservative and orthodox. But here’s the irony: many South Asians leave their countries looking for better jobs, fair laws and personal freedom. Yet, once they arrive in secular countries, they often rebuild the exact religious walls they left behind. According to Vertovec, migration to secular Western democracies does not secularise South Asians. Instead, it prompts them to self-consciously institutionalise and reconstruct sharper religious boundaries than those they navigated back home.</p> <p>Interestingly, as South Asian cities expand, their growing middle classes face the same pressures that shaped immigrants in London or Houston. Moving away from joint families into small nuclear arrangements, many among the middle classes have increasingly begun to rely on structured programmes, such as Quran academies and Sunday Bal Vihar classes. This shift is accelerated by digital media and what anthropologist Peggy Levitt terms “social remittances” or the flow of ideas and behaviours from migrants back to their homelands.</p> <p>Post-1980s Bollywood costume dramas set inside joint families and recent Pakistani ‘morality serials’ are examples of this shift. In these, lifestyle modernity is woven into an idealised portrayal of faith. The rational West-returned man or the silly hippie is long gone, systematically replaced by good looking middle class believers who have ‘rediscovered’ their faith. Even though faith in India or Pakistan was never in any danger of getting lost.</p> <p><em>Published in Dawn, EOS, November 22nd, 2026</em></p>

0

Balanced coverage

0% L100% C0% R

1 outlet covering this story

Bias Comparison

No AI summary generated for this bucket yet.

1 Article

Discussion (0)

Sign in to share your opinion.
  • No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.