Democracy in the Age of Decay
<img src="https://img-cdn.publive.online/fit-in/1280x960/greater-kashmir/media/media_files/2026/09/23/election-commissioners-flagged-issues-but-poll-body-unanimous-on-sir-decisions-officials-2026-09-23-12-23-56.png" /><p class="p6">The ongoing slugfest between the Opposition and the ruling party over alleged electoral malpractices by the Election Commission of India (ECI) is deeply troubling. Elections are the foundation of democratic legitimacy. When citizens doubt the fairness of electoral rolls or institutional impartiality, the damage extends far beyond any single election, weakening trust in the state and deepening political polarisation. India&rsquo;s strength lies in reconciling diversity with shared citizenship&mdash;a strength that must be protected through transparency and an electoral process every eligible Indian can trust.</p> <p class="p7"><span class="s2">India&rsquo;s democracy has never been merely a ritual at the ballot box. It is a living promise that every citizen holds an equal place in the political community. That promise is tested in everyday encounters between citizens and the state: from ration offices to electoral rolls.</span></p> <p class="p7">The controversy over the ECI&rsquo;s Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls brings this test into sharp focus. The ECI states the exercise ensures voter lists remain accurate and free of duplicates, under the principle that no eligible voter be excluded nor any ineligible person included. Clean rolls are essential; no credible democracy can tolerate deceased voters on registers or ineligible persons casting ballots. The issue, therefore, is not whether India should maintain accurate voter lists, but whether the process strengthens public confidence or weakens it.</p> <p class="p7"><b>When procedure becomes anxiety</b><b></b></p> <p class="p7">The SIR exercise, which began in Bihar in 2025 and expanded across other states and Union Territories, has seen contested procedures, shifting timelines, large-scale deletions, and documentation disputes. Reports cite lakhs of notices, &ldquo;logical discrepancies,&rdquo; and repeated deadline extensions.</p> <p class="p7">For ordinary Indians, these are questions of belonging, not abstract administration. Voters may be asked to establish links to older rolls or produce documents that poor, migrant, elderly, homeless, or marginalised citizens rarely possess. A name wrongly marked as absent, shifted, or duplicate turns citizenship into a bureaucratic ordeal, shifting the burden of proof onto those least equipped to navigate government offices and digital portals.</p> <p class="p7">The ECI maintains its SIR orders are unanimous and lawful, noting no name can be deleted without prior notice and a speaking order, with appeals to the District Magistrate and Chief Electoral Officer. Formal safeguards matter, yet they do not automatically create trust. Public confidence depends on whether citizens can understand the rules, obtain documents without hardship, and see errors corrected promptly. When shifting deadlines and confusing forms force voters to fight to stay on the rolls, perceived fairness suffers.</p> <p class="p7"><b>Democracy is more than voting</b><b></b></p> <p class="p7">Democracy in India is too often reduced to election day, yet voting is only one moment in a continuous process. Citizens must register without obstruction beforehand and hold governments accountable afterward through courts, legislatures, and a free press.</p> <p class="p7">Democratic backsliding rarely begins by abolishing elections. It begins quietly when legal procedures weaken oversight, political parties deepen social divisions to consolidate vote banks, and public institutions hesitate to challenge power. Media platforms reward outrage over evidence, and citizens increasingly view democratic procedures as weapons between &ldquo;us&rdquo; and &ldquo;them.&rdquo;</p> <p class="p7"><span class="s2">In this environment, the Indian state remains present&mdash;more present than ever through digital identification, surveillance, and welfare databases&mdash;while its legitimacy weakens. Citizens begin to believe rules are applied selectively, records are unreliable, or institutions serve power rather than the public. This is quiet democratic decay: institutions continue to function, yet trust departs.</span></p> <p class="p7"><b>The Kaplan warning and the Indian reality</b><b></b></p> <p class="p7">Robert D. Kaplan&rsquo;s 1994 essay, &ldquo;The Coming Anarchy,&rdquo; warned that population pressure, resource scarcity, urbanisation, and sectarian conflict could overwhelm states faster than democratic ideals could save them. He argued elections alone cannot compensate for weak bureaucracy, poor policing, environmental pressure, and social fragmentation.</p> <p class="p7">While Kaplan&rsquo;s apocalyptic tone appears overstated today, his core insight remains vital for India: democracy requires governability&mdash;the state&rsquo;s practical capacity to deliver security, justice, basic services, and equal citizenship.</p> <p class="p7">India illustrates both sides of this tension. Since 1950, it has sustained universal adult franchise and preserved its constitutional framework through wars, emergencies, and economic crises. Yet India also faces uneven development, environmental stress, urban overcrowding, communal polarisation, unequal access to justice, and pressure on independent institutions. These challenges do not make collapse inevitable, but they create conditions where public trust steadily erodes.</p> <p class="p7"><b>Electoral integrity and inclusion</b><b></b></p> <p class="p7">The SIR controversy matters because it touches the bedrock of democratic citizenship: the right to vote. A clean roll achieved through inclusive verification, clear communication, adequate time, and accessible documentation enhances Indian democracy. Conversely, an opaque, rushed, or burdensome process makes citizens feel their citizenship is conditional. Electoral integrity is not merely the absence of fraudulent votes; it is the presence of fair procedures for every eligible voter. If the state excels at flagging suspected duplicates but falters at restoring wrongly deleted citizens, it shifts the risk of administrative error onto vulnerable Indians.</p> <p class="p7"><b>Rebuilding trust</b><b></b></p> <p class="p7"><span class="s2">The remedy lies not in abandoning electoral revision, but in making it visibly fair. Under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, booth-level officers make prior intimations and door-to-door visits before treating an elector as untraceable, while draft rolls are published with a statutory period for claims and objections, backed by appeals to the District Magistrate and Chief Electoral Officer.</span></p> <p class="p7">These mechanisms must become accessible in practice. Booth-level officers should be equipped to assist vulnerable voters rather than merely hunt discrepancies. Deadlines must reflect the realities of migration, poverty, age, disability, and digital exclusion across India. Notices must use plain local languages, support every deletion with clear reasons, and offer practical routes to restoration.</p> <p class="p7">The ECI states valid grievances received during the claims-and-objections period result in names being restored before the roll is finalised. That commitment must be visible on the ground, not merely stated in press notes. Transparency means explaining decisions publicly, correcting errors promptly, and treating the Indian voter not as a potential offender, but as the source of democratic authority.</p> <p class="p7"><b>The choice before India</b><b></b></p> <p class="p7">If India demonstrates that a clean roll and an inclusive roll are the same objective, it will strengthen its democracy. If it allows citizens to believe administrative purification comes at the cost of political exclusion, it will feed the distrust on which democratic decay thrives.</p> <p class="p7">The coming anarchy, if it arrives in India, will not announce itself through collapsed capitals or empty parliaments. It will arrive quietly: through weakened courts, intimidated journalists, polarised neighbourhoods, depleted resources, unreliable records, and citizens who no longer believe the state belongs to them.</p> <p class="p7"><span class="s2">India&rsquo;s democratic story is not yet Kaplan&rsquo;s prophecy, but it reminds us democracy must be renewed in ordinary life. It proves itself not merely by removing doubtful entries, but by ensuring the poor, migrant, elderly, disabled, and politically unpopular can secure their place on the rolls without fear.</span></p> <p class="p7">Anarchy is not written into India&rsquo;s future. It becomes possible only when societies stop repairing the bonds between citizen and state, between majority and minority, and between power and accountability. The choice before India is not between perfect democracy and inevitable collapse, but between a republic renewed through fairness, trust, and inclusion, and one that slowly hollows out while preserving its outward forms. The coming anarchy will begin wherever Indian citizens are made to feel they must prove, again and again, that they belong.</p> <p class="p8">&nbsp;</p> <p class="p9"><i>The writer is a former Indian Army officer. He writes on<span class="Apple-converted-space">&nbsp; </span>issues pertaining to Jammu & Kashmir.</i></p>
Balanced coverage
1 outlet covering this story
No AI summary generated for this bucket yet.
1 Article
- Center
Discussion (0)
- No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
